Category Archives: East is East

{Review} The Teutonic Knights/ Knights of the Cross – Henryk Sienkiewicz


As read for Rose City Reader’s 2012 European Reading Challenge and The Black Sheep Dances Eastern European Challenge

Coming from England and having a mother who specialised in the Third Reich (and London’s Soho in the 1890s) [I hasten to add that she studied these areas to increase the strength of her anti-racism and pro-racial tolerance/ multiculturalism arguments] I’ve grown up with a lot of anti-Eastern European propaganda floating around.

What I wanted was a different perspective of Poland and its history and I’d say that The Teutonic Knights sheds the different light I’ve been looking for.

Blurb (full version can be found on goodreads)
The Teutonic Knights is an epic of medieval times and national destiny, ranking as one of the highest achievements from the pen of Henryk Sienkiewicz, the Nobel Prize winner for Literature in 1905.

The novel follows the adventures of Macko, a resourceful and wise veteran of war, and his young nephew, Zbyszko, the symbol of a maturing nation, as they struggle, along with the unified peoples of Poland and Lithuania, against the oppressive religious military order, the Teutonic Knights.

A host of other memorable characters fills the canvas set against lush, almost magical forests, dangerous marshes replete with tales of human heads walking on spider legs, winter blizzards that blanket the world in a white wonderland – all at once beautiful and foreboding. Splendid castles are described here, court hunts, single combats that test valour and strength. The customs of knights with their code of honour and feelings of love are adroitly explored. The entirety culminates in one of the most important battles in medieval history, the Battle of Grunwald.

Having watched the first two parts of Sienkiewicz’s Trilogy, which portrays the Germans positively, I was surprised by the two-dimensional way that he wrote about them in The Teutonic Knights. They are portrayed as savage brutes who will do anything to harm others. [Spoiler alert] The torture and eventual death of one of the main characters is tragic, even though it makes way for the love story that was always going to happen.. [/end spoiler alert]

On the other hand, I did enjoy reading a book that showed the Knights of the Cross to be not as holy as the order’s name would suggest. I also enjoyed Sienkiewicz’s way of writing about Courtly Love (I’m a real sucker for that) and about the role of religion in the Medieval period in Central/ Eastern Europe.

I love the idea of Sienkiewicz re-creating the concept of the Polish nation through this book at a time when his ‘country’ did not exist. I also really enjoyed reading a book that was pro-Poland.

Whilst it’s not my favourite of Sienkiewicz’s novels, it is definitely one that I’ll re-read at a later date (hopefully in the original language) as it had lots of elements that I really enjoy in fiction. There was romance, there was war and it was set in the Medieval period.

Wild Night In’s Verdict? Wavering towards.. win!


Tags: , , , , , , , ,

{Review} Catherine the Great: Portrait of a Woman – Robert K Massie

Pre-twentieth century Russian History. It sounds daunting and, at first glance, the 625-page tome appears to be so.

Fear not!

Massie has a way of sifting through all available information and reshaping the facts he gleans from it into a unique piece of literature. As the blurb sums up both Massie and this biography far better than I could, I’ll leave my usual waffle-y bit out.

All that remains to be said is this: ‘Perhaps the best description of her is that she is a woman as well as an empress’.

The Pulitzer Prize–winning author of Peter the Great, Nicholas and Alexandra, and The Romanovs returns with another masterpiece of narrative biography, the extraordinary story of an obscure young German princess who travelled to Russia at fourteen and rose to become one of the most remarkable, powerful, and captivating women in history.

Born into a minor noble family, Catherine transformed herself into Empress of Russia by sheer determination. Possessing a brilliant mind and an insatiable curiosity as a young woman, she devoured the works of Enlightenment philosophers and, when she reached the throne, attempted to use their principles to guide her rule of the vast and backward Russian empire. She knew or corresponded with the preeminent historical figures of her time: Voltaire, Diderot, Frederick the Great, Empress Maria Theresa of Austria and Marie Antoinette.

Reaching the throne fired by Enlightenment philosophy and determined to become the embodiment of the “benevolent despot” idealized by Montesquieu, she found herself always contending with the deeply ingrained realities of Russian life, including serfdom. She persevered, and for thirty-four years the government, foreign policy, cultural development, and welfare of the Russian people were in her hands. She dealt with domestic rebellion, foreign wars, and the tidal wave of political change and violence churned up by the French Revolution that swept across Europe. Her reputation depended entirely on the perspective of the speaker. She was praised by Voltaire as the equal of the greatest of classical philosophers; she was condemned by her enemies, mostly foreign, as “the Messalina of the north.”

The story is superbly told. All the special qualities that Robert K. Massie brought to Nicholas and Alexandra and Peter the Great are present here: historical accuracy, depth of understanding, felicity of style, mastery of detail, ability to shatter myth, and a rare genius for finding and expressing the human drama in extraordinary lives.

History offers few stories richer in drama than that of Catherine the Great. In this book, this eternally fascinating woman is returned to life.

One mistake that is sometimes made when writing a historical biography is referring to events without contextualizing them. No chance of that here: Massie draws different threads such as Catherine’s feelings/ beliefs, foreign interests, Russian Court intrigues and issues in contemporary Russia together, weighing their impact and the impact of events on these different elements. As a result, one cannot help but have respect for Catherine’s strength of will and her statesmanship, even on occasions when she shows ‘complete misunderstanding’ of a situation, such as when she writes and publishes a pamphlet calling for the release of Louis XVI and Marie Antoinette after their second arrest.

At times, Massie goes one step further showing for example, Catherine’s evolving opinion of serf freedom and then going on to say that they had to wait until her grandson’s ascension before they were granted it. The most mind-boggling example of the impact of Catherine’s actions was the partitioning of Poland in 1795. Poland only regained self-governance in 1918 (although I’m willing to debate that point with people), 123 years later. The only mark of my ever having been here in 123 years time will probably be a few dozen plastic bags, rotting in a pile of toxic waste somewhere. Verdict It is a long book, packed with facts and (relevant) anecdotes. Not afraid of taking an extra page or two to describe other noteworthy characters, including John Paul Jones, a Captain in the American Navy during the Revolutionary War. This adds to the rich illustration of Catherine’s life, character and surroundings whilst remaining engaging until the end.

Thank you, Massie for re-introducing me to History! I’m off to find a copy of his ‘Peter the Great’.

Wild Night in: Win!

NB: Read for the European Reading challenge as hosted by rosecityreader


Tags: , , , , , ,

Eastern European Books

As hosted by theblacksheepdances

Reading List: (TBR/ review pending in italics)
1) Catherine the Great: Portrait of a Woman – R. Massie – Russia
2) The Teutonic Knights – H. Sienkiewicz – Poland
3) Melancholic Waltz – Z. Hejda –
Czech Rep.
4) —

Leave a comment

Posted by on March 9, 2012 in East is East


Tags: , ,

%d bloggers like this: